Top 10 cheddar cheese brands in the United States

User avatar placeholder
Written by Robert Gultig

2 May 2025

Introduction

Cheddar cheese is one of the most popular types of cheese in the United States, known for its rich flavor and versatility. With a wide variety of brands available in the market, consumers often seek the best options for their culinary needs. In this report, we will explore the top 10 cheddar cheese brands in the United States, focusing on their market presence, financial performance, and industry insights.

1. Tillamook

Overview

Tillamook is a well-known cheddar cheese brand based in Oregon, founded in 1909. The company is renowned for its high-quality dairy products, including cheddar cheese, butter, and ice cream. Tillamook’s cheddar cheese is made from locally sourced milk and aged to perfection, resulting in a rich and creamy flavor that consumers love.

Financial Data

Tillamook reported annual revenue of over $1 billion in 2020, making it one of the leading cheddar cheese brands in the United States. The company’s strong financial performance is attributed to its commitment to quality and innovation in dairy products.

2. Cabot Creamery

Overview

Cabot Creamery is another prominent cheddar cheese brand in the United States, based in Vermont. Established in 1919, Cabot is known for its award-winning cheddar cheese made from the finest milk sourced from local dairy farms. The brand offers a wide range of cheddar cheese varieties, from mild to extra sharp.

Financial Data

Cabot Creamery reported annual revenue of approximately $400 million in 2020, demonstrating its strong market presence in the cheddar cheese industry. The brand’s commitment to sustainability and community support has also contributed to its success.

3. Kraft

Overview

Kraft is a household name in the United States, known for its wide range of food products, including cheddar cheese. The brand offers a variety of cheddar cheese options, from shredded to sliced, catering to different consumer preferences. Kraft’s cheddar cheese is popular for its convenience and quality.

Financial Data

Kraft reported annual revenue of over $25 billion in 2020, making it one of the largest food companies in the United States. The brand’s strong distribution network and marketing strategies have contributed to its success in the cheddar cheese market.

4. Sargento

Overview

Sargento is a leading cheddar cheese brand in the United States, known for its high-quality cheese products. The brand offers a wide range of cheddar cheese varieties, including traditional blocks, slices, and snacks. Sargento’s cheddar cheese is made from 100% real cheese, without any artificial flavors or preservatives.

Financial Data

Sargento reported annual revenue of over $1 billion in 2020, highlighting its strong market position in the cheddar cheese industry. The brand’s commitment to quality and innovation has earned it a loyal customer base.

5. Cracker Barrel

Overview

Cracker Barrel is a well-known cheddar cheese brand in the United States, offering a range of premium cheese products. The brand’s cheddar cheese is aged to perfection, resulting in a bold and rich flavor that sets it apart from competitors. Cracker Barrel’s cheddar cheese is popular for its quality and taste.

Financial Data

Cracker Barrel reported annual revenue of over $500 million in 2020, reflecting its strong performance in the cheddar cheese market. The brand’s commitment to tradition and craftsmanship has made it a favorite among cheese enthusiasts.

6. Organic Valley

Overview

Organic Valley is a leading organic cheddar cheese brand in the United States, known for its commitment to sustainable farming practices. The brand’s cheddar cheese is made from organic milk sourced from family-owned farms, ensuring high quality and environmental responsibility. Organic Valley offers a range of cheddar cheese options, from mild to sharp.

Financial Data

Organic Valley reported annual revenue of over $1 billion in 2020, highlighting its strong market presence in the organic cheddar cheese segment. The brand’s focus on organic ingredients and environmental stewardship has resonated with consumers seeking high-quality and sustainable cheese products.

7. Kerrygold

Overview

Kerrygold is an Irish cheddar cheese brand that has gained popularity in the United States for its rich and creamy cheese products. The brand’s cheddar cheese is made from grass-fed cow’s milk, resulting in a unique and flavorful taste. Kerrygold offers a range of cheddar cheese varieties, including aged and flavored options.

Financial Data

Kerrygold reported annual revenue of over $1 billion in 2020, demonstrating its strong market presence in the cheddar cheese industry. The brand’s commitment to quality and authenticity has made it a favorite among cheese connoisseurs.

8. Tillamook

Overview

Tillamook is a well-known cheddar cheese brand based in Oregon, founded in 1909. The company is renowned for its high-quality dairy products, including cheddar cheese, butter, and ice cream. Tillamook’s cheddar cheese is made from locally sourced milk and aged to perfection, resulting in a rich and creamy flavor that consumers love.

Financial Data

Tillamook reported annual revenue of over $1 billion in 2020, making it one of the leading cheddar cheese brands in the United States. The company’s strong financial performance is attributed to its commitment to quality and innovation in dairy products.

9. Kroger

Overview

Kroger is a well-known supermarket chain in the United States that offers its own brand of cheddar cheese. The Kroger brand cheddar cheese is known for its affordability and quality, making it a popular choice among consumers. Kroger offers a variety of cheddar cheese options, from blocks to shredded.

Financial Data

Kroger reported annual revenue of over $120 billion in 2020, highlighting its strong market presence in the retail industry. The brand’s private label cheddar cheese products have contributed to its overall success in the market.

10. Great Value

Overview

Great Value is a private label brand owned by Walmart, offering a range of affordable cheddar cheese products. The brand’s cheddar cheese is known for its value and quality, catering to budget-conscious consumers. Great Value offers a variety of cheddar cheese options, from blocks to slices.

Financial Data

Walmart reported annual revenue of over $500 billion in 2020, making it one of the largest retail companies in the world. The Great Value brand’s cheddar cheese products have contributed to Walmart’s overall success in the market.
In conclusion, the top 10 cheddar cheese brands in the United States offer a diverse range of options for consumers, from traditional to organic and premium varieties. These brands have established themselves as leaders in the cheddar cheese market, with strong financial performance and a commitment to quality and innovation. Whether you prefer a sharp aged cheddar or a mild and creamy option, there is a brand to suit every taste and budget in the competitive cheddar cheese industry.

Related Analysis: View Previous Industry Report

Author: Robert Gultig in conjunction with ESS Research Team

Robert Gultig is a veteran Managing Director and International Trade Consultant with over 20 years of experience in global trading and market research. Robert leverages his deep industry knowledge and strategic marketing background (BBA) to provide authoritative market insights in conjunction with the ESS Research Team. If you would like to contribute articles or insights, please join our team by emailing support@essfeed.com.
View Robert’s LinkedIn Profile →