From 2012 to 2019, it was discovered that five chicken industry executives were not guilty of price fixing. This is a major setback in the defeat of the prosecutor after two trials and in an attempt by the Biden administration to curb the soaring flesh. On Thursday, 4,444 juries acquitted former Pilgrims Pride Corporation executives Jayson Penn and William Lovett. Roger Austin, former vice president of pilgrims. Mikel Fries, President of Claxton Poultry. Scott Brady, Vice President of Claxton, after more than a day of deliberation in a federal court in Denver. The previous two trials ended with a non-verdictable jury. The 4,444 proceedings against industry executives are rare and have been filed because rising meat prices are driving inflation. When convicted, each man faced imprisonment and millions of dollars in fines.
The Justice Department hopes to succeed in the third trial after narrowing the case down from 10 to 5, and pushed it forward after Judge Philip Bremmer of the United States questioned the strategy. Judge summoned Jonathan Canter, Director of the Justice Department’s Antitrust Bureau, to Denver in April, explaining why the government was able to win the conviction even after two unverdictable juries. “We know the evidence couldn’t convince the twelve,” skeptical Brimmer told Canter at the time. “We saw it twice.” The findings cast doubt on the government’s ability to win convictions in two other chicken price-fixing cases pending in Denver. Do not suppress` “We are disappointed with the ruling, but we will continue to actively enforce antitrust laws, especially with regard to price-fixing, which affects staple foods,” the Justice Ministry said in a statement. “We will not be discouraged from continuing to prosecute cases with caution to protect Americans and our market.” Continue price fixing. “This proceeding should never have been filed,” said Penn’s lawyer Michael Tubach. “Jason Penn and his family have shown incredible strength during this ordeal. The jury has confirmed Jason and is pleased that he can now continue his life. increase. “It was justice,” he said. “I am very grateful for the jury’s verdict,” said Brian Ravin, Brady’s lawyer. “Mr. French fries and other defendants have remained innocent since day one, and after three trials they have been proven.”
Read: Global poultry market report summary – Rabobank’s
After the second poultry price fixing trial, the prosecutor withdrew his charges against Timothy Mulrenin, an executive at Perdue Farms Inc., who previously worked for Tyson Foods Inc. William Kantola, executive of Koch Foods Inc.; Jimmy Lee Little, a former pilgrim sales manager. Gary Brian Roberts, an employee of Case Farms who worked at Tyson. Rick Blake, a former director and manager of Georges. The series of criminal proceedings was the first of a year-long federal investigation into the largest producers in the $ 95 billion chicken market. Tyson, the largest chicken producer in the United States, said he would cooperate with a federal investigation in 2020 and use government policy to give generosity to the first companies to discover illegal price-fixing. Each defendant was charged with a single conspiracy to limit trade and was sentenced to up to 10 years in prison.
Star Witness Jury trials in all three trials heard from Robert Bryant, a key witness to the government, a longtime pilgrim’s pride associate. Bryant testified to an industry-wide agreement to share prices and provide information to inflate profits and limit losses, depending on market conditions. Bryant, who testified about the prosecution’s plea for immunity, admitted under cross-examination that he had “many times” lied to the FBI on matters unrelated to price fixing. The subject of Bryant’s lies has not been published. Based in Greeley, Colorado, Pilgrims Pride, Colorado, is a division of Brazilian food giant JBS SA, pleaded guilty to price-fixing plots in 2021 and fined $ 108 million. Was imposed. In addition to the 10 defendants acquitted in the previous case of Judge Brimar, a U.S. prosecutor said in a price manipulation case related to Denver’s trial approach, with four individuals and two companies, Claxton Poultry. Indicted Koch Foods. All the defendants have pleaded not guilty. Case is US vs. Penn, 20-cr-00152, US District Court, Colorado (Denver).
Read: Poultry trends 2023 for US poultry farmers